Why I'm Not Afraid of Saturated Fat Anymore
Saturated fat is the enemy—or so I'd been told by doctors, nutritionists, and health organizations for my entire life.
Then I started questioning that advice, added saturated fat back to my diet, and something unexpected happened: my health improved.
The Fear I Was Taught
From childhood, I absorbed the message that saturated fat would clog my arteries and kill me. This wasn't presented as theory—it was stated as biological fact.
Butter was bad. Coconut oil was dangerous. Red meat would give me heart disease. The solution was margarine, vegetable oils, and lean protein.
I followed this advice faithfully while my health declined.
The Contradiction I Couldn't Ignore
If avoiding saturated fat worked, why did chronic disease explode during the decades when everyone followed low-fat advice?
Americans reduced their saturated fat intake starting in the 1970s and 1980s. We replaced butter with margarine and vegetable oils. We chose low-fat everything.
And we got sicker. Much sicker.
What Changed My Mind
I started researching the actual studies that created our fear of saturated fat. What I found surprised me: the evidence linking saturated fat to heart disease was far weaker than I'd been led to believe.
Many of the foundational studies had serious methodological problems. Correlation was treated as causation. Alternative explanations were ignored.
Yet these flawed studies became the basis for dietary guidelines that shaped how millions of people ate for decades.
The Experiment That Changed My Life
Eventually, I decided to test the advice I'd been following. What if I ate real butter instead of margarine? What if I stopped avoiding egg yolks and didn't trim every bit of fat off my meat?
The low-fat approach hadn't worked for me, so what did I have to lose?
What Happened Next
Within weeks of adding saturated fat back to my diet, I noticed changes:
More stable energy throughout the day
Reduced cravings for sugar and carbs
Better satiety after meals
Improved mental clarity
Paradoxically, easier weight management
My labs? They improved too. The cholesterol numbers that supposedly would skyrocket with saturated fat actually got better.
The Research I Wish I'd Known Earlier
As I dug deeper, I found numerous recent studies questioning the saturated fat-heart disease connection. Large meta-analyses finding no significant link. Research showing that replacing saturated fat with refined carbohydrates actually worsens health outcomes.
This research exists in peer-reviewed journals, but it doesn't make it into mainstream dietary advice or doctor recommendations.
The Quality Question
Not all saturated fat is the same, just like not all calories are the same. Butter from grass-fed cows is different from industrial margarine. A grass-fed steak is different from a fast-food burger.
But dietary guidelines treat all saturated fat as identical, missing crucial distinctions about food quality and sourcing.
Why the Old Advice Persists
If the evidence for avoiding saturated fat is weak, why do health organizations still recommend limiting it?
Changing long-standing guidelines is difficult. Admitting that decades of advice might have been wrong is uncomfortable. And there are economic interests in maintaining the status quo.
So outdated recommendations persist while people continue following advice that may not serve their health.
What This Means for You
I'm not suggesting everyone needs to eat tons of saturated fat. What I'm suggesting is that you've been given oversimplified advice based on questionable science.
The relationship between dietary fat and health is far more nuanced than "saturated fat bad, vegetable oils good."
What I Explore in the Book
In my upcoming book, I dive into:
The flawed research that created our fear of saturated fat
Why low-fat recommendations coincided with worsening health outcomes
What recent, large-scale studies actually show about dietary fat
The crucial differences in fat quality that guidelines ignore
How I changed my relationship with fat and improved my health
Beyond Fear-Based Eating
The best nutrition advice shouldn't require you to fear real foods that humans have eaten for thousands of years while embracing industrial products created in the last century.
Maybe it's time to question whether our fat phobia has served us well—or whether it's been one of the biggest nutritional mistakes of the modern era.
Ready to reconsider everything you've been told about dietary fat? Subscribe to my blog for weekly insights that challenge conventional nutrition wisdom.